#25 JooBee's newsletter

TL;DR

šŸ„‡ Want to convince your founder? Start with this crucial first step

šŸ‘€ When the "obvious" solution to HR isn't solving the actual problem

ā“ Your views on influence

This newsletter edition is brought to you by Parallel Employee Benefits šŸ’›

Did a friend forward this newsletter your way? šŸ“©

Subscribe for practical ā€˜how-toā€™ tips to transition your start-up from creative chaos to repeatable performance - in all things people, teams and organisation.

Question:  How can I convince my CEO to balance the initiatives he wants HR to do with those I believe are best for our employeesā€™s experience?

Head of People

Want to convince your founder? Start with this crucial first step

While conducting user research for my Strategic HR Leadership bootcamp, one of the most common challenges for HR leaders I hear about is gaining buy-in to implement certain HR initiatives. Here are some common themes:

  • How can I convince my founder to implement A?

  • How can I persuade my founder to allocate a budget for B?

  • How can I demonstrate to my founder the need to prioritise C?

When I asked HR leaders how they try to influence their founders, hereā€™s what most of them shared:

  • Showcase research: ā€œHereā€™s how other companies are doing it.ā€

  • Present data: ā€œImplementing X will boost productivity by Y%.ā€

  • Share feedback: ā€œOur employees are asking for Z.ā€

And yet, founders may still disagree. Even with logical arguments and clear benefits, they still resist šŸ¤·šŸ»ā€ā™€ļøšŸ¤¦šŸ»ā€ā™€ļø. Why?

What we are trying to do is ā€“ ā€˜teachā€™ others our solution is right

If we are honest with ourselves, the information we present is to support our caseā€”i.e., our ā€œsolution.ā€ Essentially, when weā€™re trying to influence others, we are ā€œteachingā€ them that our solution is the right one. And what usually follows? More resistance.

ā

When we disagree, itā€™s typically at solution level

We often present our ideas as specific solutionsā€”such as implementing regular feedback, introducing a career framework, or adding new processes. When founders (or stakeholders) push back, itā€™s usually because they disagree with the proposed solution itself. This can trap us in a cycle of either debating the solution or trying to ā€˜fixā€™ the solution to gain acceptance.

Shift the level of conversation: From solution disagreement to problem alignment

If I tell you I will never hire a DEI specialist role in my team, some of your eyes might be popping out like cartoon characters right now reading this statement šŸ‘€. However, if I tell you the problem I want to solve is (1) I want everyone in the business (including everyone in the HR team) to be accountable for DEI, and (2) I want to make systematic changes to everything we do to be more inclusive.

Would you disagree with that? Most likely not. So, when you encounter disagreement or pushback, the first step is to check alignment on the problem we want to solve ā€“ and dig deep into it, beyond just surface-level issues.

Solve problems, donā€™t solve solutions

When we disagree at the solution level, we often try to ā€œfixā€ the solution itself. For example, suppose your founder says leadership training is taking too many hours away from managersā€™ daily responsibilities. You might address this by shortening the trainingā€”thatā€™s just ā€œfixing the solution.ā€ 

But, if you dig deeper, you might discover that the real issue is that your founder doesnā€™t fundamentally believe that training will make a difference despite agreeing that upskilling leaders is necessary. Now youā€™ve identified the true problem! Thereā€™s no point in merely adjusting the training; instead, you can now move on from training as a solution and explore alternative options.

Collaborate, donā€™t compromise!

Iā€™ll leave you with a framework to keep in mind when approaching disagreements:

Thomas-Kilmann's model

If you align on the problem, you wonā€™t have to compromise on the solution. Youā€™ll collaborate to findā€”nay, innovateā€”alternative solutions you might never have considered before. This is a true win-win situation!

When the "obvious" solution to HR isn't solving the actual problem

How difficult is it to create a salary increase letter template? šŸ¤·šŸ»ā€ā™€ļø Typically, itā€™s a quick job - just a few minutes, or at most an hour. You'd need to cover; employee name, company details, date, introduction and purpose of the letter, achievements, salary increase and effective date, contractual implications and a thank you note at the end. 

Simple right? At one start-up I worked for, the process was anything but simple. My founder was adamant about cutting out the ā€˜contractual implicationsā€™ section in our salary letters. I was like, ā€œWait, what? Thatā€™s pretty much standard!ā€ After consulting with our legal team, they confirmed it three timesā€”it was non-negotiable!šŸ™…šŸ»ā€ā™€ļø

My founder and I went back and forth for a week. It seemed like an obvious necessity to me, but we were stuck in a loop of disagreement. With the clock ticking, we had to get these letters out pronto!

I forgot: solve problems, donā€™t solve solutions šŸ¤¦šŸ»ā€ā™€ļø

So, I decided to sit down with my founder and really listen. I asked him why it was crucial to exclude the contractual details. I discovered he wanted each employee to feel like a ā€˜hero of their journeyā€™ when they received the letter, not just another piece of corporate paperwork.

We do make our salary letters highly personalisedā€” every manager takes the time to write a custom note to be included in the salary letters. They will highlight both company and individual achievements with a celebratory tone. The founder was concerned that any ā€œlegaleseā€ might kill the positive vibe. He understood the importance of including contractual implications but wanted to ensure they didnā€™t detract from the positive energy of the letter.

It was a win-win! We did not compromise, we collaborated

By aligning on the true problemā€”ensuring the letterā€™s tone remained celebratory while still including the necessary contractual detailsā€”my team crafted a solution that was far from a wet blanket (check it out below!). 

Salary increase letter

Hereā€™s an example of a personalised salary increase letter for Daniel Gualdino on my team. You'll find the 'small print' at the bottom, which covers the contractual implications. āš ļøFair warning: We love our emojis in that company.

Small Print: How we made ā€˜legaleseā€™ upbeat (shoutout to Sami Maiden!)

What do you thinkā“

What is the ONE thing you find most DIFFICULT to influence in your role as a LEADER?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

šŸ”— LinkedIn | šŸŒŽ JooBeeā€™s blog | šŸ¤ Work with me